Sonic Cinema

Sounds, Visions and Insights by Brian Skutle

Gentle Monster

Grade : A Year : 2026 Director : Marie Kreutzer Running Time : 1hr 54min Genre : , ,
Movie review score
A

For much of “Gentle Monster,” Lucy Weiss (Léa Seydoux) must rely on what she is told in order to make the right decisions for herself and her family. A concert pianist, her emotions come out in her performance, where she eschews performing classical pieces for pop music. It’s not a financially lucrative life, but it’s one that means something to her. When something happens that challenges everything she thought she knew about her husband, Philip (Laurence Rupp), she must navigate the wreckage of everything as best she can.

Writer-director Marie Kreutzer’s film makes painful subject matter palatable, in part because of the way she’s chosen to write Lucy and Philip, and also how she keeps one of the detectives on the case,
Elsa Kühn (Jella Haase), as a part of the story. She is an observer and confidant for Lucy- although legally, there’s only so much she can do- but she also is dealing with some difficulties in her personal life. She is trying to take care of her father, who seems to have Alzheimer’s, and she’s having trouble keeping caregivers for him.

I can only imagine the challenge of what it’s like to find out that a loved one is not the person you thought they were. When the police come to take Philip’s hard drives in the morning, we can infer as to why, but the conversation Lucy and Philip have is made difficult because their son, Johnny (Malo Blanchet), is asleep. When he’s off to school, Lucy goes to the police station, and tries to get some answers. Evidently, this is not the first time Philip has had trouble with law enforcement, but it’s not really explained how. All that matters is this situation, what is true, and what is being kept from Lucy. The police don’t tell her everything. Philip is not telling her everything. His friend and lawyer is trying to stay committed to his friend and client. And Lucy cannot really tell anyone, including her mother (Catherine Deneuve), even after her and Johnny go to stay with her after the investigation starts.

Kreutzer’s film allows its reveals to come gradually, as the characters learn them. Deep down, I had my own ideas on the truth, but watching it play out on screen made everything land just a bit harder as Lucy discovers it. Seydoux is fantastic in the role of Lucy, giving us a woman trying to keep things together for her son, and her family, but having trouble finding a release until she cannot hide the truth any more. As the detective, Haase is also worth a mention, especially in one moment where she sees Lucy and her whole family together, getting ready for a family trip. She has a discussion about it with her partner later that feels judgemental, but as we’ll see later, she will have her own choices she has to make. In the end, both women must figure out the path forward for themselves. “Gentle Monster” is powerful, and painful, to experience with both women.

Leave a Reply